Multiple insiders have been active at Bank First Corp (BFC): 4 distinct insiders account for 6 buy filings and 1 sell filing as of Apr 2026. Its highest-significance filing in the last 90 days: Director Stayer-Suprick Michael S bought $32K, transaction dated Apr 2026.
Historically, high-priority insider buys have outperformed the S&P 500 by a median ~2% over the 30 days after the trade — the edge is concentrated in that first month (n ≈ 5,579, 2024-2026). Past results don't predict the future. How we measure this ↗
Bank First Corp insider purchased 225 shares at $140.04 per share (total $31,509) on open market, increasing position by 5.1%. This represents meaningful insider confidence in the stock's value.
Director Sprang Todd A. bought 450 shares of Bank First Corp (BFC) at $138.96 on 2026-04-22, increasing holdings 28.8% to 2,015 shares.
Director Sprang Todd A. purchased 450 shares at $138.96, representing a substantial 28.8% increase in his shareholding from 1,565 to 2,015 shares. The transaction occurred when BFC was trading -6.6% from its 52-week high of $151.84, and the stock has since rallied +6.1% over the past 30 days. However, his prior BFC purchase on 2026-01-27 shows a negative 30-day return of -0.7%, and his cross-ticker track record across all open-market buys averages -0.7% over 30 days, providing limited confidence in his buy-timing accuracy. The company trades at a P/E of 20.74 with a $1.6B market cap and $18.0M net income, positioning it as a mid-cap financial institution where insider buying patterns warrant monitoring for signals of management conviction, though historical execution does not yet demonstrate consistent timing success.
Bank First Director Eldred Steven M sells 16,000 shares across two transactions for $2,375,760.00
Director Eldred Steven M executed 2 separate sales totaling 16,000 shares for $2,375,760.00, reducing his holdings from 141,680 shares to 125,680 shares, a -11.3% reduction in his position. The transactions were priced at $145.02 and $151.95 on consecutive trading days, with blended average price of $148.48, compared to the current price of $145.17. The stock is within 4.4% of its 52-week high of $151.84 and has appreciated 17.4% over the past 30 days, reflecting positive near-term momentum. With a P/E of 20.22 and market cap of $1,427,748,837.21, the company operates at a moderate valuation multiple; the sale occurred in the context of recent strength in the stock.
Director Todd A. Sprang buys 150 BFC shares at $141.06; holdings rise to 1,158 shares (+14.9%)
Todd A. Sprang, a director of Bank First Corp, purchased 150 shares at $141.06 on January 27, 2026, increasing his stake by 14.9% from 1,008 to 1,158 shares. The purchase occurred near the 52-week high of $139.54, with the stock up 14.6% over the preceding 30 days. At a market cap of $1.4B and P/E of 19.43, the company is profitably trading at a moderate valuation. The transaction represents a discretionary buy by a director during a period of recent price appreciation, though the modest share count and dollar value ($21.2K) relative to the company's $18.0M net income limit the signal strength.
Director Michael S Stayer-Suprick purchases 410 BFC shares at $122.67; prior same-ticker buy achieved +14.6% in 90 days.
Director Michael S Stayer-Suprick purchased 410 shares of Bank First Corp at $122.67 on 2025-08-19, increasing his holdings to 3,965 shares (+11.5% vs pre-transaction). This follows a prior open-market buy at the same ticker on 2025-02-19 that generated a +14.6% return over 90 days, and his cross-ticker track record shows 1 prior buy with a 100.00% 90-day win rate and +14.6% average 90d return. The current price of $122.89 sits 7.1% below the 52-week high of $132.29 and has declined 3.3% over the past 30 days, placing the entry point in a period of recent consolidation within a broader uptrend (+7.3% over 90 days). The company has a P/E of 17.46, market cap of $1.2B, and reported net income of $16.9M, suggesting a mid-sized financial institution at historical valuation levels.
Director Daniel C. McConeghy bought 380 shares of BFC at $105.72, raising holdings to 2,000 shares (+23.5%).
Director Daniel C. McConeghy purchased 380 shares of Bank First Corp at $105.72 on March 4, 2025, increasing his position by 23.5% to 2,000 shares total. The transaction occurred near the upper end of the stock's 52-week range of $75.81–$108.79, at a price only 4.6% below the 52-week high. The company's fundamentals show a P/E ratio of 14.03 on net income of $16.6M and a market cap of $1.0B, providing a stable backdrop. The stock has gained 2.3% over the prior 30 days and 3.4% over 90 days, showing modest positive momentum at the time of the purchase.
Director Michael S Stayer-Suprick purchased 1,000 shares of BFC at $102.07; post-transaction holdings 3,035 shares (+49.1%)
Director Michael S Stayer-Suprick purchased 1,000 shares at $102.07 on 2025-02-19, increasing his holdings from 2,035 to 3,035 shares—a 49.1% increase in his position. The transaction occurred near the upper end of the stock's 52-week range ($75.81–$108.79), with the current price at $103.15 representing a modest 5.2% discount from the 52-week high. BFC trades at a P/E of 12.46 with a $1.0B market cap and $16.6M net income, suggesting a modestly valued regional bank. The substantial percentage increase in director holdings represents meaningful accumulation of equity stake and warrants monitoring for any forthcoming strategic announcements or material developments.
