CASY CASEYS GENERAL STORES INC Insider Trading

Director Spanos buys 300 CASY shares at $665.43; post-transaction holdings: 4,499 shares. Prior 5 CASY buys: 100% well-timed at 90-day mark.

Director Mike Spanos purchased 300 shares of Casey's General Stores at $665.43, increasing his holdings to 4,499 shares. This represents a +7.1% addition to his prior position. The transaction is noteworthy given Spanos's demonstrated track record at this specific ticker: his 5 prior purchases at CASY were uniformly well-timed at the 90-day mark, with returns ranging from +1.8% to +27.9% over that period. The current price of $673.27 is 1.1% above the transaction price in the near term and +21.8% above the 30-day average, suggesting near-term price appreciation. Spanos's 83.33% win rate across his cross-ticker track record (6 prior buys, average 90-day return +8.6%) combined with his perfect 5-for-5 timing at CASY specifically warrants investor attention to his positioning ahead of any near-term developments at the company.

Director Castanon Moats Maria purchases 300 CASY shares at $554.66; holdings rise 59.6% to 803 shares

Director Castanon Moats Maria purchased 300 shares of Casey's General Stores at $554.66 on 2026-01-05, increasing her shareholding by 59.6% from 503 to 803 shares. The transaction occurred near the 52-week high of $573.58, just 1.7% below the peak, in a stock trading at a P/E of 34.42 and market cap of $20.9B. The company reported annual revenue growth of 7.2% and latest quarterly revenue of $4.5B with net income of $206.3M. This open-market acquisition by a board member represents a material increase in director-level ownership stake and reflects continued exposure to the business, though the timing relative to the stock's near-peak valuation and elevated P/E warrants investor observation of accompanying disclosures or strategic context.

Chief HR Officer Chad Michael Frazell sold 3,487 shares of CASY at $555.40, reducing holdings to 7,993 shares (-30.4%)

Frazell sold 3,487 shares worth $1,936,679.80 at $555.40 on 2025-09-29, cutting his holdings by 30.4% and leaving 7,993 shares remaining. The transaction occurred near the 52-week high of $565.32, with the stock trading at that peak on the filing date. His prior three sales at CASY (all on 2025-06-17) posted mixed 90-day returns ranging from +9.8% to +10.2%, with none exhibiting downside protection; similarly, his cross-ticker track record of 3 prior sells showed a 0.00% well-timed rate against 90-day benchmarks. The current P/E of 36.15 and annual revenue growth of +7.2% position CASY as a premium-valuation growth story, but the insider's substantial reduction in ownership concentration warrants monitoring of whether underlying fundamentals remain intact to justify the current price.

Director Mike Spanos buys 200 CASY shares at $503.18; 4 of 4 prior buys at ticker showed positive 90-day returns, latest at 27.9%.

Mike Spanos, a director, acquired 200 shares of Casey's General Stores on 2025-06-30 at $503.18, increasing his holdings by 6.0% to 3,560 shares. This purchase extends a pattern of insider activity at this ticker: his prior 4 open-market buys at CASY (2025-03-13, 2024-12-23, 2024-09-18, 2024-01-03) all generated positive 90-day returns, with the most recent prior buy posting a 90-day gain of 27.9%. His cross-ticker buy track record shows an 80.00% 90-day win rate with an average 90-day return of 10.9% across 5 prior transactions. The stock is currently trading at $510.64, near its 52-week high of $510.91, and has appreciated 16.6% over the past 30 days and 15.0% over 90 days. The 100% success rate of his prior CASY buys at the 90-day mark represents a statistically notable pattern worth monitoring as this position matures.

CLO Lindsey Katrina S sells 2,000 CASY shares at $506.07; holds 4,239 post-transaction amid -1.5% annual revenue growth.

Chief Legal Officer Lindsey Katrina S sold 2,000 shares of Casey's General Stores for $1,012,140.00 on 2025-06-17, reducing her holdings by 32.1% to 4,239 shares. The sale occurred at $506.07, near the 52-week high of $507.63, though the stock has since declined to $500.27. The underlying business context is mixed: the company reported $3.9B in quarterly revenue but faces -1.5% annual revenue growth, and trades at a P/E of 34.69. A single officer's stock sale at elevated valuation levels warrants monitoring, though the reduction in personal holdings is material relative to her prior position.

CASY CFO Bramlage sells 8,478 shares (24.1% of holdings) for $4.3M at $509.21 blended price

Chief Financial Officer Stephen P Bramlage JR executed 2 separate sales totaling 8,478 shares for $4,317,045.95 on 2025-06-17, reducing his holdings from 35,232 shares to 26,754 shares. The sales occurred at a blended average price of $509.21, near the 52-week high of $507.63 and well above the current price of $506.31. The stock has appreciated 11.0% over 30 days and 28.2% over 90 days, suggesting the company's operational performance has recently strengthened. With the P/E at 35.11 and annual revenue growth at -1.5%, the valuation premium persists despite underlying revenue headwinds, which provides context for the CFO's significant reduction in personal exposure at elevated price levels.

CASY CEO Darren M Rebelez sold 20,000 shares for $10,156,643.27 on 2025-06-17 near 52-week peak of $507.63

President and CEO Darren M Rebelez executed 9 separate sales totaling 20,000 shares for $10,156,643.27 on June 17, 2025, reducing his holdings from 109,840 to 89,840 shares (an 18.2% reduction). The blended average transaction price of $507.83 places the sales just 0.3% below the 52-week high of $507.63, with the stock up 11.0% over the preceding 30 days and 28.2% over 90 days. His prior 5 sales at CASY on September 6, 2024 were followed by positive 90-day returns (ranging 11.2% to 12.4%), meaning he did not successfully time those earlier exits; of his cross-ticker open-market sell history, his 90-day well-timed rate is 0.00%. The sale occurs at an elevated valuation: the stock trades at a P/E of 35.11, and the company's annual revenue declined 1.5% year-over-year despite a $3.9B latest-quarter revenue base. Given the proximity to all-time highs and the pattern of prior sales that missed subsequent gains, the timing and magnitude of this liquidation merit investor attention.

CASY Chief HR Officer Frazell sells 4,808 shares at $503.97 avg ($2.4M), retains 11,480 shares post-sale.

Chad Michael Frazell executed 3 separate sales totaling 4,808 shares for $2,423,110.49 at prices ranging from $503.53 to $505.43, reducing his holdings by 29.5% to 11,480 shares. The sales occurred on 2025-06-17 near the stock's 52-week high of $507.63 (current price $506.31 is 0.3% below that peak), following significant recent momentum: the stock gained 11.0% over 30 days and 28.2% over 90 days. As a Chief HR Officer rather than a C-suite executive with direct operational or financial authority, Frazell's trading activity carries lower information weight than senior officers such as the CFO or CEO. The decision to liquidate a substantial portion of his position during a period of strong price appreciation warrants tracking to see whether it reflects his personal liquidity needs or portfolio management rather than any signal about company fundamentals or forward outlook.

COO Koschel Williams Ena sells 8,000 shares for $4.1M at $507.97 avg (within 0.3% of 52-week high)

Koschel Williams Ena, Chief Operating Officer of Casey's General Stores, executed 6 separate sales totaling 8,000 shares for $4,063,747.73 on 2025-06-17, reducing her holdings from 26,059 to 18,059 shares. The blended average price of $507.97 sits within 0.3% of the 52-week high of $507.63, coinciding with a period of significant short-term momentum (30-day and 90-day gains of +11.0% and +28.2% respectively). Her prior sale at this ticker on 2024-09-10 was followed by positive 90-day returns of +11.2%, indicating a pattern where her exits have not preceded subsequent declines. The timing of this sale at the 52-week high range warrants attention given the company's -1.5% annual revenue growth and elevated P/E of 35.11.

Chief Merch. Officer Brennan Thomas P JR sells 6,600 shares of CASY at $506.03; reduces stake by -75.9% to 2,100 shares

Brennan Thomas P JR, Chief Merchandising Officer, sold 6,600 shares at $506.03 on 2025-06-16, reducing his holdings from 8,700 to 2,100 shares—a -75.9% reduction in his position. The sale occurred at a price -0.1% from the 52-week high of $506.99, amid an 11.0% gain over the preceding 30 days and a 30.9% gain over 90 days. His prior open-market sell at this ticker on 2024-09-06 generated a -2.5% 30-day return and a +10.5% 90-day return, indicating the stock rose after that sale rather than declined. The current trade's timing relative to near-peak pricing and strong recent momentum creates observable context for investor monitoring, though no scheduled trading plan is indicated.