DGICA DONEGAL GROUP INC Insider Trading

10% owner Mutual Insurance Co Donegal acquired 17,000 shares at $16.93 blended avg; cross-ticker win rate 50%, same-ticker mixed (3 of 5 well-timed).

Mutual Insurance Co Donegal, a 10% shareholder, executed two purchases totaling 17,000 shares for $287,806.60 at a blended average price of $16.93, adding 0.1% to its 14.10M share position. The current price of $17.00 sits 19.3% below the 52-week high of $21.06, while the company's annual revenue growth stands at -1.2% with latest quarterly revenue at $235,996,234.00. Across the insider's cross-ticker history, prior open-market buys averaged +0.9% return in 30 days but only -3.8% in 90 days (50% win rate). At DGICA specifically, the insider's prior 5 purchases show mixed results: 3 of 5 were well-timed at the 90-day mark, though the two most recent purchases (2026-05-20 and 2026-05-19) each posted -0.5% and -0.8% 90-day returns. The stock has declined 4.4% over the past 90 days despite a recent +3.6% gain over 30 days.

Donegal Insurance (10% owner) bought 8,500 shares of DGICA at $16.98, extending 5-trade buying streak despite stock -19.0% from 52-week high

Mutual Insurance Co Donegal, a 10% shareholder, purchased 8,500 shares on 2026-05-28 at $16.98, adding to a concentrated position of 14.08M shares. This represents the fifth consecutive open-market buy at DGICA within 14 days (2026-05-14 through 2026-05-28), with prior trades showing mixed near-term performance: three of the five prior same-ticker buys posted positive 90-day returns. The stock is currently trading at $17.07, down 19.0% from its 52-week high of $21.06, and has declined 5.2% over the past 30 days. Fundamentals show revenue of $236.0M and net income of $11.5M in the latest quarter, but annual revenue declined 1.2% year-over-year, signaling headwinds that may explain the price weakness and the insider's continued accumulation during a period of relative underperformance.

10% owner Mutual Insurance Co Donegal bought 17,000 shares at avg $17.24 across 2 transactions; holdings now 14.07M shares.

Mutual Insurance Co Donegal, holding 14.07M shares post-transaction, made 2 separate purchases totaling 17,000 shares for $293,068.10 at an average price of $17.24 on May 26–27, 2026. The current price stands at $17.06, reflecting a -3.8% move over 30 days and -3.6% over 90 days from the transaction dates, while the stock trades -19.0% below its 52-week high of $21.06. Across this insider's prior trades at DGICA, 3 of 5 prior buys were well-timed at the 90-day mark, though the two most recent prior purchases (May 20 and May 19) showed modest negative returns at both 30 and 90 days. The company's fundamentals show revenue of $235,996,234.00 and annual revenue growth of -1.2%, suggesting a mature or declining business context. The acquisition of an additional 0.1% of holdings represents a modest incremental position increase by an already-dominant 10% shareholder.

10% owner Mutual Insurance Co Donegal buys 17,000 shares at $17.44 avg over 2 days; stock down 17.3% from 52-week high

Mutual Insurance Co Donegal, the 10% holder, executed 2 separate purchases totaling 17,000 shares for $296,509.75 on 2026-05-21 and 2026-05-22 at a blended average price of $17.44. The current price of $17.42 sits -17.3% from the 52-week high of $21.06. At this ticker, the insider's 5 prior trades show a mixed pattern: 3 of 5 prior buys were well-timed at the 90-day mark, though the two most recent purchases on 2026-05-20 and 2026-05-19 posted slightly negative 90-day returns. The continued accumulation represents a modest 0.1% increase to holdings (14.06M shares), and the company faces headwinds with annual revenue declining 1.2% year-over-year against net income of $11.5M on quarterly revenue of $236.0M.

10% owner Donegal Insurance Co buys 16,828 shares in 2 transactions for $293,719.87 at avg $17.45

Mutual Insurance Co Donegal, a 10% owner, executed 2 separate purchases totaling 16,828 shares for $293,719.87 on 2026-05-19 and 2026-05-20 at a blended average price of $17.45, expanding holdings to 14,039,109 shares. The current price of $17.44 sits -17.4% from the 52-week high of $21.12, and the stock has declined -1.2% over the past 30 days. Prior trades at this same ticker show 4 of 5 preceding buys posted positive 90-day returns, with the most recent buy on 2026-05-12 posting +1.2% over 90 days. The company's annual revenue growth stands at -1.2%, with latest quarterly revenue of $235,996,234.00 and net income of $11,510,604.00. The purchases occur amid modest near-term price weakness and flat annual growth, though the insider's cross-ticker track record shows a 30.00% win rate on the 90-day horizon with an average 90d return of -6.2%.

10% owner Mutual Insurance Co Donegal purchases 17,000 shares across two dates for $293,182.00 at DGICA

Mutual Insurance Co Donegal, a 10% shareholder, made 2 separate purchases totaling 17,000 shares for $293,182.00 on consecutive trading days (2026-05-15 and 2026-05-18) at blended average price $17.25. The current price is $17.49, and the stock is -17.2% from its 52-week high of $21.12 and -2.0% over the past 30 days. At DGICA specifically, this insider's prior 5 trades exhibited positive 90-day returns ranging from +0.3% to +3.2%, with 4 of 5 prior buys well-timed at the 90-day mark—establishing a pattern of favorable post-purchase price action at this ticker. The acquisition increases holdings from 14,005,281 shares to 14,022,281 shares (+17,000 shares, +0.1% net change), and fundamentals show latest quarterly revenue of $235,996,234.00 with annual revenue growth of -1.2%. The timing and consistency with prior same-ticker purchase outcomes merit monitoring for directional signal, though the holding increase as a percentage of existing position remains modest.

Donegal Mutual (10% Owner) makes 2 purchases totaling 17,000 shares for $289,123.25, lifting stake to 14,005,281 shares at DGICA.

Mutual Insurance Co Donegal, a 10% owner, filed 2 separate purchases totaling 17,000 shares for $289,123.25 at blended average price $17.01, bringing its post-transaction holding to 14,005,281 shares. At the 90-day mark, 4 of 5 prior buys at DGICA showed positive outcomes, with the most recent buy on 2026-05-12 posting +1.2% at the 90-day mark. As a separate current-price observation, DGICA is trading at $17.18, which is -18.7% from its 52-week high of $21.12. On the fundamental side, the latest quarterly revenue was $236.0M against net income of $11,510,604.00, with annual revenue growth of -1.2% year-over-year.

10% beneficial owner Mutual Insurance Co Donegal buys 17,000 shares in two tranches; mixed near-term vs. longer-term timing on prior DGICA purchases.

Mutual Insurance Co Donegal, a ten-percent beneficial owner, purchased 17,000 shares of Donegal Group in two tranches on consecutive trading days in May. This is the institutional holder's 177th and 178th open-market purchase in the past three years, continuing a sustained buying pattern with no recorded sales. Historically, three of five prior purchases at this ticker have been well-timed in the near term as the stock gained afterward, though all five of those purchases ultimately proved poorly-timed over a longer horizon as shares declined. The company itself remains profitable with stable recent quarterly results, though annual revenue declined slightly year-over-year. The conflicting timing outcomes—short-term gains followed by longer-term declines—suggest the stock has experienced recovery rallies that fail to sustain, a pattern this repeat buyer has encountered multiple times before.

10% owner Mutual Insurance Co Donegal purchases 16,577 shares at persistent lows; prior buying at this stock mixed in timing but consistent in conviction.

Mutual Insurance Co Donegal, a 10% beneficial owner of Donegal Group, acquired approximately 16,600 shares over two trading days in early May at prices near the stock's 52-week low—a portfolio accumulation move typical of institutional holders managing large positions. The stock has declined meaningfully from its 52-week high and is down over the past three months, creating a backdrop where the institutional holder is adding to exposure. This is the continuation of a sustained pattern: the owner has purchased shares at this company on five separate occasions over the prior months, though those earlier buys produced conflicting results—well-timed entries over shorter timeframes but poor outcomes over longer horizons, suggesting the stock dipped after entry and then extended declines. The repeat buying despite prior unfavorable longer-term outcomes signals persistent appetite despite recent weakness, though it does not guarantee the current purchases will prove well-timed. Donegal Group itself remains profitable with stable operations, so the institutional holder is accumulating shares in a fundamentally sound company while it trades at a discount to recent levels.

Donegal's 10% owner adds 17,000 shares on consecutive days while stock trades well below highs; mixed track record on prior buys raises questions.

Mutual Insurance Co Donegal, a 10% institutional holder in Donegal Group, purchased shares on two consecutive days totaling over $280,000, doubling down as the stock trades significantly below its recent highs. The company remains profitable with solid revenue, providing a financially stable foundation for this purchase. However, the 10% owner's track record in this specific stock presents a cautionary tale—while they have been a consistent buyer, prior purchases haven't produced the returns an investor would hope for, with most subsequent periods showing the stock moved lower rather than higher. This latest purchase suggests the institutional holder sees current prices as attractive, but the lack of success timing these same purchases before suggests patience and careful scrutiny are warranted rather than viewing this as a vote of confidence in an imminent recovery. The repetition of buying despite mixed prior results raises the question: is this conviction based on fundamental value, or is it a portfolio positioning decision unrelated to near-term company performance?